Aww snap, DOTAFire mentioned on PCGamer

I played DotA 1 for about six years before playing DotA 2.

I don't write guides because I won't feel good about down votes and bad feedback.

How about before you can downvote or upvote a guide, you must put a reason for it. That way people will know if it wasn't just a downvote of jealousy. And if the downvotes are indeed false, people could report false downvotes and downvoters get a warn, however reporting valid downvotes/upvotes gives the person who reported an increase in warn level.


Now if someone put 5 sentences into his reason, only the author should be able to reply and explain his guide. Just mix up the comments section of a guide with the upvote/downvote system.

Now for if you wanted to give the author an advice to improve his guide, the person needs some way to say it but the comments section would be gone, hmmm, so i guess don't remove the comments section and add another tab below the guide instead. one would be comments the other would be votes.