Bubble, the Bubble

{R}: Bubbles
Lol, this is most OP. Have you thought about if someone is clever enough, they will just keep making copies and hide them some where, when they have like 100 copies they control them to all attack at same time then it will be gg...
So I suggest you to make maximum copies or actually make a duration...

Unless the game goes to 400 minutes, there is no way this hero can get anywhere near 100 copies lol

I know, I was just making an example lol, my meaning is that they can make alot of copies that DEAL 100% and RECEIVE 100% damage, won't that be OP?

And you can confuse enemies ALOT, since there is no way to identify which one is the real maybe except for Medusa's Stone Gaze..?

True, there is indeed a flaw in the ultimate. Also, my comments in the double post have been deleted. No offence, but I simply don't agree with the idea. I don't see how this hero could be useful other than with the aforementioned strategy with mass Bubbles floating around, and even then it would take 40 minutes for him to amass such an army (which pretty much lasts for only a few pushes/fights/???).


I will summarise what I said in that post:
No damage, no disables, buffs not strong enough, hard for stats to be higher than teammate's a bit later, bubbles needs rework
Suggestions are -- give Child-like Memories bonus out-of-combat regeneration (few seconds after teammate gets hit), give Strength in Weakness active ally purge component, replace Free Floating with Dreamburst (when activated, self becomes invulnerable and moves faster, then after a few seconds explodes and deals damage to enemies and slows, with some time of invulnerability afterwards), add max limit to Bubbles but decrease cooldown.

Look Sofa, I'm not going to be rude or anything, but... are you kidding me? I really, really think that this one is just sort of a bait (and if it, I have eaten it). I won't go so far as saying that this hero is absolutely horrible, but well... I nominate this hero as one of the hero you should do a complete reboot (including ALL his skills, lore, stats and even name, like... what kind of hero has the same name as his title?)

So yeah, you wish for my 'fire', here it is:
(Sorry to be quite, err.... very harsh, but I am being objective here, and I will try not to put my personal feeling as possible)

Let's start this one with overall analysis, okay? I can see that this hero do not have any primary attribute, and that is just pushing it. I know that this might be balancing for his absurd stats and stats gain, but... no, it's better if you just pick an attribute and reduce the stats. Now, I mentioned the absurd stats, and by absurd, I mean horrendously stupefying. There is only one hero in Dota that have same stats and stats gain, which is Bane, BUT, he only has 22 + 2.1 in all stats, and this hero trumps that by A LOT, 30 + 3 in all gives him an edge of 24 total stats in level one and 2.7 total stats advantage per level, and that is just crazy (since it would be 24*2.7 = 64.8 stats at lvl 25), basically all the highest tier stats item. The role that you said he should be is a solo-offlaner, and that really doesn't fit his skills. 2 of his skills (both Q and W) are abilities that benefits ally, and you saying that he should be solo-offlaner really doesn't make sense that way, although his other skill is an escape skill (the only skill he has that actually fit him being solo-offlaner). I know that you probably wants him to have lvl advantage for his W, but I cannot see him being his best in there.

Now unto the skills, shall we? I'll start with his Q skill, Child Like Memory (can we do something for that name?) To me, this skill is too much of a troll skill (imagine this situation: Keeper of the Light at level one without strength item would have 416 HP, and this hero lane with him. The moment an enemy want to jump to Keeper of the Light, the player of this hero decided to just use this skill, reducing the HP to 116, well... you get the point). I would say that precisely because of this, the skill is horribly designed. Anyway, let's crunch them numbers okay? I think this skill is quite (if not really) overpowered, and the way you balance it with armor reduction and 300 max HP reduction is not that wise. Let's go for the HP regen first, okay? 20 at the final level is really, really strong ( Tranquil Boots only provide 12), and even if compared to Voodoo Restoration, it heals half of the amount WITHOUT mana cost (in fact, healing it). This leads us to the second point, mana restoration, now, this part is absolutely freaking totally broken, you can LITERALLY turn this skill on in any kind of time without EVER turning it off, providing permanent 20 MP restoration ( Clarity only providing 3.75). The 20 move speed is really useless though, I don't see the point of that. Anyway, this skill very, very odd, I would much rather if you can just put in MP cost to the toggle (at least to self), remove the HP recovery as well as the strange drawback of the skill (300 HP and armor reduction), while reducing the MP recovery and increasing movement speed. I guess around 1/2/3/4 MP recovery and 20/30/40/50 movement speed would be nice at the cost of 20 MP per second?

Second skill now, I think this one might take more time since it is even more broken than the previous skill. This skill is PASSIVE, which means it will give substantial boost to HP, MP and attack speed to all heroes by huge amounts because of his ridiculous base stats. Want me to do the counting? Here I go: Assume no item at level one, the maximum amount to max HP it can give to a friend would be to Medusa (again), which is (30-14)*5 = 80, which is not that crazy, but then comes level 7 and let's count it again, the number become crazy (30+3*6) = 48, which is this hero STR at that level, and medusa is just (14+1.8*6) = 23.9 (24). That gives Keeper of the Light crazy amount of HP, which is (48-24)*20 = 480 HP (approximately 2 Vitality Booster for free, which is around 2,200 gold), which gives him 606+480 = 1086 HP at level 7, defeating even his HP at level 16 (which is only 910). And that is just the HP part, what about MP? I'll use Troll Warlord the maximum amount for MP it provide. 48 would be this hero INT at level 7, while troll would only have (13+1*6) = 19. This means (48-19)*20 maximum MP, do you want me to count it? It's freaking 580 at level 7, defeating even Scythe of Vyse that provides only 455 MP and Bloodstone that gives 500 MP. Well, what about attack speed? Let's use Tiny for this one, he will have only (9+0.9*6) = 14.4 (14). This means (48-14)*20 attack speed, which is.... 680 freaking attack speed. Well, if I have to say something.... CAN YOU PLEASE, PLEASE RECALCULATE? I mean, 680! Even Focus Fire only give you 500 bonus attack speed (which is the maximum attack speed). This is by no definition balanced. Although this skill's idea is really interesting, I find it hard to really suggest anything since this skill can only be too OP or too UP, so I'd suggest actually recreating this skill (or even hero, since this hero is based on this skill). God that took so long.

E skill? I would like to say more, but this skill is really, really limited in commenting. Why? You don't write how levelling it change anything. I like that idea, but the ability to freely phase through obstacle to be OP. You probably want to combine Firefly and Phase Shift, but this skill is just horribly designed. It's probably better if you combine the phasing power with something else and do the scaling. Currently, it's just too abstract for me to actually comment.

And the ultimate skill? Basically what I said for the E skill, and let's just forget about the obvious (what have already been said), and even if you put in actual timed life or limit, I think it's still pretty much OP (but at the same time UP because of its low synergy to the rest of the skill), it's like Meepo without any risk, and actually having more of this hero is not nearly as beneficial as Meepo, it's just going to practically make your aura global. However, the damage and tanking power it gives would be good.

To sum it all up is that this hero lack synergy with his skills and roles, he doesn't make much sense and you didn't bother at all to create scaling (notice how his E and R has none at all and how Q and W use basic 5/10/15/20). Anyway, some of this hero's skills are pretty interesting and you have done some very original works here, but this hero seems more like a lump of idea piled together without any concept in mind (which leads to him being invalid in real game). I really advise if you take one skill you would like to use and expand from it from scratch. I'm sorry if I am being really harsh with my words, no offence :)

P.S: Wow, ZERO damage, really? And you still said that this hero is a solo-offlaner? Sorry, but this hero need a total redesign

Holy moly,

Yzreel coming back with a bang it seems :p